WASHINGTON — House Oversight Committee Democrats launched the Master ICE Tracker on Monday, establishing the first federal intake form to document and verify allegations of misconduct by federal immigration enforcement agents during the Trump administration’s mass deportation campaign.
MIGRANT INSIDER is sponsored by:
Rep. Robert Garcia, the committee’s ranking member, announced the tracker last month at a press conference in Los Angeles alongside Mayor Karen Bass, calling it an essential tool to hold the Department of Homeland Security accountable for what he described as unconstitutional enforcement tactics.
“American citizens are being dragged off the streets by masked men and thrown into detention cells without access to a lawyer or even a phone call,” Garcia said during the announcement. “No one, regardless of their background or appearance, should be living in fear of being thrown behind bars by their own government because of their race or what they look like”.
The database will compile verified incidents of possible misconduct committed during interior immigration enforcement operations, categorizing each case under types including “concerning use of force,” “concerning arrest/detention,” “concerning deportation,” and enforcement actions at sensitive locations such as schools, churches, and hospitals.
MIGRANT INSIDER is sponsored by
A Response to Escalating Violence
The tracker’s launch comes as federal immigration agents have deployed increasingly aggressive tactics across American cities. Border Patrol influencer Gregory Bovino, who has led high-profile operations in Chicago and Los Angeles, admitted under oath that he lied about being struck by a rock before deploying tear gas against demonstrators in Chicago’s Little Village neighborhood—a violation of a federal judge’s temporary restraining order.
Federal Judge Andrea Wood, who heard Bovino’s testimony, said his admission “calls into question everything that defendants say they are doing” and their characterization of enforcement activities.
ProPublica’s investigation, which helped spur the tracker’s creation, found that more than 170 U.S. citizens have been detained by immigration agents during Trump’s second term, with at least 50 held due to questions about their citizenship and approximately 130 arrested on allegations of assaulting or interfering with officers—charges that frequently wilted under scrutiny or were dismissed.
Federal agents have used tear gas dozens of times in Chicago alone, with two-thirds of those incidents appearing to target peaceful demonstrators or bystanders, according to reporting by the Race and Equity Project. In one September operation, nearly 300 federal agents rappelled from Black Hawk helicopters onto a South Shore apartment building at night, using explosives to breach doors and zip-tying residents including small children.
Garcia’s Background as Pro-Migrant Champion
Garcia, 47, has been a vocal advocate for immigrant rights throughout his political career. The first openly LGBTQ immigrant elected to Congress, Garcia immigrated to the United States from Peru as a child and became a naturalized citizen under President Ronald Reagan’s Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986.
As mayor of Long Beach from 2014 to 2022, Garcia moved aggressively to protect the city’s immigrant, Muslim, and LGBTQ residents when Trump first took office. He was the city’s first immigrant mayor and youngest mayor, launching progressive initiatives including tuition-free community college and a universal basic income pilot program.
Garcia now leads House Oversight Democrats alongside Senate counterpart Richard Blumenthal, who chairs the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. Together, they have opened a joint bicameral investigation demanding DHS Secretary Kristi Noem provide comprehensive records on citizen detentions.
Border Patrol’s Culture of Impunity
The tracker directly confronts what civil rights organizations describe as a decades-long crisis of accountability within U.S. Customs and Border Protection. Nearly 200 people have died from encounters with Border Patrol over the past 15 years, including 70 use-of-force cases and six people killed in cross-border shootings—yet no agent has ever been convicted of criminal wrongdoing while on duty.
James Tomsheck, CBP’s former internal affairs chief, warned in 2014 that the agency “goes out of its way to evade legal restraints” and is “clearly engineered to interfere with efforts to hold the Border Patrol accountable”.
The Trump administration has now elevated Border Patrol leadership to top positions within ICE field offices across the country, replacing nearly half of career ICE officials with current or retired Border Patrol officers despite the agency’s notorious track record.
Historical Context for Federal Agent Oversight
The Master ICE Tracker follows a long tradition of federal oversight mechanisms designed to combat law enforcement misconduct, though its public-facing nature marks a departure from traditional complaint systems.
The Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Inspector General was established in 2002 alongside DHS itself under the Homeland Security Act, with a hotline to receive complaints about waste, fraud, abuse, and misconduct. Similarly, the Justice Department’s Office of Inspector General has accepted complaints about DOJ employees since passage of the Inspector General Act of 1978, which established 12 federal OIG offices to ensure integrity and efficiency in government.
The USA Patriot Act of 2001 specifically directed the Justice Department’s Inspector General to review information and receive complaints about civil rights and civil liberties abuses by DOJ employees. More recently, the Justice Department launched a whistleblower rewards program in 2024 to incentivize reporting of corporate and government misconduct.
However, these traditional mechanisms have proven insufficient for tracking immigration enforcement abuses. ICE itself has investigated 414 employees or contractors since 2016 for misusing confidential databases—including cases of stalking, harassment, and sharing information with criminals—yet experts describe the agency as consistently “pushing to the limits of what they are allowed to do” without meaningful oversight.
Trump Administration Backlash
The tracker immediately drew fierce criticism from Trump administration officials. Attorney General Pam Bondi accused Democrats of endangering agents, while Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons claimed the tracker “puts a target on the backs of ICE agents”.
House Administration Committee Chairman Bryan Steil, a Wisconsin Republican, announced he would block Democrats from hosting the tracker on House committee websites, forcing Garcia to find alternative hosting.
However, investigations by Colorado Public Radio and NPR found federal court data shows only a 25 percent increase in assault charges—nowhere near the administration’s claims. DHS has refused to release data substantiating its figures despite multiple media requests.
MIGRANT INSIDER is sponsored by:
Sensitive Locations No Longer Protected
The tracker will especially flag enforcement actions at sensitive locations, a category that lost all federal protections when Trump rescinded Biden-era guidance on his first day in office. Immigration agents can now conduct arrests at schools, churches, hospitals, and courthouses without restriction.
Under the Biden administration’s 2021 policy, these locations were designated as “protected areas” where enforcement actions were discouraged to ensure access to essential services. The Trump administration’s reversal has led to widely reported arrests near schools in Denver and outside churches in Washington, D.C., though some religious institutions have obtained court injunctions protecting their premises.
Building a Record for Accountability
Garcia and Blumenthal have demanded DHS begin tracking comprehensive information on how many U.S. citizens the department detains and provide regular updates to their committees. Their November 18 letter to Secretary Noem accused DHS of making “false statements” denying that citizen detentions have occurred.
The tracker represents Democrats’ most ambitious effort yet to create transparency around immigration enforcement—a campaign Garcia vowed would continue “until this Administration is held accountable”.
If you’ve read this far, you understand why news like this matters. Subscribe or donate to help Migrant Insider grow.
