WASHINGTON — In a sharply worded letter dispatched to top officials at the Department of Homeland Security and Immigration and Customs Enforcement this week, House Democrats Robert J. Menendez (NJ) and Dan Goldman (NY) called for an immediate federal response to reports that immigration officers frequently conduct arrests without properly identifying themselves, in apparent violation of federal law.
MIGRANT INSIDER is sponsored by:
Citing ongoing incidents nationwide, the lawmakers’ letter—which was sent on November 10—expresses “deep concern” over accounts of ICE and other federal immigration officers executing arrests while obscuring their identities, sometimes concealed behind masks and lacking name tags or badge numbers. Such tactics, they wrote, “undermine public trust and stoke fear in our communities.”
Federal regulation under 8 C.F.R. 287.8(c) requires immigration enforcement officers to promptly announce their authorized status “as soon as it is practical and safe to do so.” This legal mandate is reinforced by judicial settlements, including the notable Castanon Nava v. Dept. of Homeland Security case, which obligates ICE to document the circumstances and justification for warrantless arrests and vehicle stops.
MIGRANT INSIDER is sponsored by
Menendez and Goldman’s letter demands answers to five pointed questions, with a response deadline of November 21. The congressmen seek details on how DHS monitors and enforces officer compliance with identification requirements, what standards officers must meet for timely identification, how many complaints were logged in 2025 about officers failing to identify themselves, and what disciplinary action, if any, followed such complaints. The letter also calls for a comprehensive explanation of ICE training protocols regarding officer identification.
“These violations of legal requirements,” Menendez and Goldman wrote, “endanger the rights of individuals and the integrity of law enforcement operations.” They argue that prompt and clear identification by federal officers is essential for protecting constitutional rights, preventing wrongful arrests, and fostering public accountability.
The lawmakers referenced investigative reporting that documented “masked and unmarked” immigration raids, casting these practices as emblematic of the Trump administration’s approach to immigration enforcement—one they say risked violating Fourth Amendment protections and sowed confusion among the public.
The letter concludes with a direct plea to DHS and ICE leadership: “Rectify ongoing violations of legal requirements and uphold the rights and dignity of all individuals subject to immigration enforcement.”
No immediate comment was available from ICE or DHS regarding the lawmakers’ demands. As Congress continues its oversight of federal immigration practices, the issue of officer transparency remains under a bright spotlight—and may yet trigger new DOJ guidance or corrective action, depending on the agencies’ forthcoming response.
If you’ve made it this far, you care. Help me keep pressing the powerful for answers. Subscribe or donate to keep Migrant Insider going.
