How ICE Tactics Empower Predators
Federal officers are detaining people in silence and shadows—fueling fear, enabling crime, and breaking the public trust.
WASHINGTON — From Los Angeles to New York, federal immigration officers are conducting masked raids in unmarked vehicles, detaining individuals without identifying themselves — and, in some cases, without being who they claim to be. As impersonators exploit the confusion to commit crimes, lawmakers and local officials are demanding action. But with the Trump administration intensifying immigration enforcement, it remains unclear what, if anything, will change.
MIGRANT INSIDER is sponsored by
In a letter dated Friday to Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, House Oversight Committee members Robert Garcia (D-CA) and Summer Lee (D-PA) called the use of concealed identities and unmarked vehicles by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents “a dangerous erosion of public trust, due process, and transparency in law enforcement.”
They cited recent incidents in major cities where ICE agents wore masks and refused to identify themselves during residential raids. In Los Angeles, photos emerged in June of ICE officers conducting arrests with faces covered. In Chicago, witnesses reported masked officers detaining people without presenting credentials. And in New York, former mayoral candidate Brad Lander was arrested by masked agents in an incident that drew national condemnation.
“These tactics contradict longstanding democratic principles such as the public’s right to accountability from those who enforce the law,” the letter states, warning that they make it “nearly impossible for individuals to determine whether they are being detained by legitimate law enforcement agents or unlawfully abducted.”
Crimes and Copycats
As agents move in secrecy, criminals have moved in. The Oversight Committee letter cites a growing list of ICE impersonation incidents, from a robbery in Philadelphia where a man wearing a fake badge and tactical vest zip-tied a woman and stole $1,000, to a case in Houston where a man posing as an agent took $1,800 from a Guatemalan immigrant.
In Florida, a woman used an ICE shirt and sheriff’s card to kidnap her ex-boyfriend’s wife. In Anaheim, two teenagers in a blue SUV used fake ICE credentials to rob Latino residents.
These cases, according to lawmakers, are not aberrations — they are a direct consequence of real ICE agents operating with few identifying marks and even fewer rules. “The use of masks, unmarked vehicles, and minimal identification by actual ICE agents does not just erode trust—it effectively hands bad actors a roadmap to exploit vulnerable communities,” the letter warns.
MIGRANT INSIDER is sponsored by:
Unmasking the Policy
Calls for reform are spreading beyond Congress. In San Jose, Councilmember Peter Ortiz is drafting a policy requiring ICE agents to wear identification while operating in the city. “Masked ICE agents and people impersonating them pose threats to public safety,” Ortiz said in a statement to San José Spotlight. He plans to introduce the measure in partnership with the nonprofit Amigos de Guadalupe once the City Council returns in mid-August.
Sen. Alex Padilla (D-CA) is going further. In addition to re-introducing a bill that would offer legal permanent residency to immigrants who have lived in the U.S. for seven years, Padilla is also pushing legislation to ban federal immigration agents from wearing face coverings during public enforcement operations and to require visible identification. Co-sponsored by Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.), the bill is a long-shot in a Republican-controlled Congress — but it reflects growing concern over ICE's opaque enforcement style.
A Child’s DNA in a Criminal Database
At a House Oversight hearing last week, Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-MA) blasted the Trump administration for collecting DNA from immigrants — including children — and feeding it into an FBI database designed for tracking violent criminals.
“This administration is turning childhood trauma into a permanent record,” Pressley said. “Children as young as four years old have not consented to the collection of their DNA. That is a violation of their civil rights and civil liberties.”
Pressley questioned DHS Inspector General Joseph Cuffari about the practice. Cuffari denied knowledge of a policy targeting children, but later acknowledged his office had written a report on DHS’s DNA collection. Pressley pressed him to commit to a formal investigation, citing Title 5 of the U.S. Code, which tasks his office with investigating civil rights abuses.
“You traumatize children by conducting their DNA [collection] without their consent and criminalizing them,” Pressley said, directing her remarks toward Republican committee members. “This is the real child abuse.”
MIGRANT INSIDER is sponsored by
What Are Lawmakers Doing?
Lawmakers have now begun a coordinated push to expose and potentially reverse these enforcement tactics. Garcia and Lee’s letter demands detailed documentation from DHS by August 8, including all policies related to ICE agents’ use of masks, unmarked vehicles, and concealed identities; records of internal complaints; and reviews of legal implications for Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights.
Their letter also calls attention to a new phenomenon: ICE attorneys in immigration court proceedings refusing to identify themselves. According to The News from the States, this concealment undermines accountability and may violate judicial ethics.
Despite these efforts, legislative momentum faces steep odds. Immigration reform bills — including Padilla’s green card proposal and the bipartisan DIGNITY Act introduced by Reps. María Elvira Salazar (R-L) and Veronica Escobar (D-TX) — are stalled in committee.
Meanwhile, Republicans have expressed little interest in reining in ICE’s tactics, even as local governments report communities retreating in fear. In Santa Clara County, officials say fewer people are attending community events or even going to the grocery store. Some are self-deporting.
Still, Democrats argue that the stakes are too high to remain silent.
“In America, we are not supposed to fear being kidnapped by masked agents with no names,” Rep. Lee said. “And children are not supposed to be treated like criminals for existing.”
Liked this story? Help us break the next one. Migrant Insider is one of the only outlets digging deep into the secret machinery behind U.S. immigration policy. Our reporting is independent, relentless, and often uncovers what others won’t touch.